Do I need physical damage on every truck?
Not necessarily. It's usually required only on financed or leased vehicles. Paid-off older units can go without collision, though comprehensive is often worth keeping for theft and fire.
The coverage that typically repairs or replaces your own trucks, vans and trailers after a crash, theft, fire or flood. How comprehensive and collision differ, how a total loss is usually valued and when stated values make sense.


Quick answer
Physical damage insurance generally pays to repair or replace your own trucks, vans and trailers. Collision typically covers crashes and rollovers; comprehensive usually covers theft, fire, flood, vandalism, glass and other losses that aren't a collision. It's generally optional unless a lender or lessor requires it, and what it pays depends on valuation: actual cash value on most forms or a stated amount you set for each unit.
Commercial Auto + Fleet Insurance
CaliforniaUp to 50 VehiclesWe’re here to help.
Physical damage is the half of a business auto policy that generally protects your own vehicles rather than other people. It's usually bought in two parts, each with its own deductible, and you can often choose them vehicle by vehicle: A new financed box truck might carry both, while a paid-off, high-mileage pickup carries neither.
| Question | Collision | Comprehensive |
|---|---|---|
| What triggers it | Your vehicle overturns or hits another vehicle or object | Almost anything else: theft, fire, flood, vandalism, falling objects, glass |
| Typical claims | Rear-ending another truck, backing into a pole, sliding off a wet shoulder | A stolen trailer, a van damaged in an overnight break-in, a windshield cracked by gravel, a truck caught in a wildfire or flood |
| Hitting a deer or other animal | Not usually | Usually counted here |
| Who caused it | Pays either way; your carrier may recover from the other driver's insurer | Fault rarely applies |
Some carriers also offer specified causes of loss, a narrower alternative to comprehensive that lists the perils it covers, such as fire, theft, flood and vandalism, rather than the broader approach comprehensive usually takes. It can make sense on older units where full comprehensive isn't worth carrying.
Our California commercial auto insurance page shows how physical damage fits with liability and the rest of the policy.
Unless you choose otherwise, physical damage typically pays actual cash value (ACV): what the truck was worth just before the loss, accounting for age, mileage and condition. For a common pickup with plenty of sales data, ACV tends to be easy to establish and fair.
Trucks with expensive bodies and upfits are harder. A service body with a crane, a box truck with a liftgate and refrigeration or a bucket truck with an insulated boom can be worth far more than the chassis's book value suggests. Stated amount coverage lets you put a value on the declarations page for each unit, so the carrier can see and rate the whole truck. On most forms, that number is a ceiling, not a promise: The carrier pays the least of the stated amount, ACV or the cost to repair. Set it too low, and a total loss may pay only that figure; inflate it, and you pay premium for value you likely can't collect. Either way, keep the upfit invoices that help prove what the body is worth.
The trade-offs are laid out side by side in how a total-loss truck gets valued.
Financed and leased trucks add a lender. The lender will usually require comprehensive and collision, set a maximum deductible and be named as loss payee, so a claim check typically goes to both of you. Some carriers offer loan or lease gap coverage for the difference between ACV and what you still owe.
Comprehensive is usually the coverage that responds to California's big events. The Department of Insurance's 2025 consumer alert reminds drivers that comprehensive auto coverage typically pays for flood damage and that a flood or mudslide exclusion may not apply when the loss follows a recent wildfire. After the Los Angeles fires, the Department counted 5,597 auto claims as of February 5, 2025; by November 17, 2025, its wildfire claims tracker showed 42,121 claims across all lines of insurance, with $22.4 billion paid.
Theft is the steadier risk. The CHP counted 7,331 trailers stolen in California in 2025, and 80.0% of stolen commercial trucks were recovered, against 84.0% of all stolen vehicles. A recovered truck is often stripped or damaged, and one that's never found is usually treated as a total loss valued under your policy's terms.
Yard security, GPS trackers and hitch locks on parked trailers can all help, and underwriters often ask about them at each garaging address.
Official sources
A jetter truck carries a high-pressure jetting unit, a water tank and hose reels that can be worth more than the chassis. If that equipment is permanently mounted, build it into the vehicle's value; see plumbing contractor commercial auto insurance.
A bucket truck's boom and insulated platform make up much of its value, and a rollover or a boom strike can be a near-total loss. These units are often prime candidates for stated values; bucket truck insurance gets its own page for that reason.
Trailers parked overnight at a yard or a curb are easy to hitch and drive away. Each one usually needs its own physical damage line, and the mower on it is generally equipment, not auto; more on landscape truck insurance in California.
Box trucks with liftgates and refrigeration units often pick up damage in docks and alleys: a post clipped while backing, a liftgate bent against a curb. Collision typically handles those; see box truck insurance for distributors and box truck insurance quote.
Roofing flatbeds and conveyor trucks carry costly loading equipment, and a truck parked under trees or near a fire-prone hillside is exposed to comprehensive losses. List conveyors and loaders with the truck; see roofing contractor commercial auto insurance.
Deductibles are usually chosen per vehicle and per coverage. A higher collision deductible can make sense on a well-maintained fleet with few at-fault crashes, and a lender may cap how high you can go on financed units. For a fleet adding several financed trucks a year, our page on fleet insurance for 11 to 25 vehicles covers renewal planning.
Older trucks are worth a yearly look. Once a pickup's value drops close to a year of collision premium plus the deductible, many owners drop collision and keep comprehensive for theft and fire.
Rental reimbursement and towing are modest add-ons where carriers offer them, and they can help keep a crew working while a truck is in the shop. If you rent trucks for short jobs, damage to the rental usually isn't covered by your owned-vehicle physical damage; that takes hired auto physical damage, often added alongside hired and non-owned auto insurance.
Not necessarily. It's usually required only on financed or leased vehicles. Paid-off older units can go without collision, though comprehensive is often worth keeping for theft and fire.
A stated value that leaves out the service body, crane or liftgate can underpay after a total loss. Declare the whole unit.
On most forms, the carrier pays the least of the stated amount, actual cash value or repair cost. Set values honestly and update them yearly.
Wildfire and flood damage to a truck is generally a comprehensive claim. Without it, a vehicle lost in a fire usually isn't covered under the auto policy.
Next Level Experience. Insurance Done Right.
Fleet quotes for California businesses running up to 50 trucks and vans.